您的位置首页百科问答

JMC

JMC

如题:JMC 小修竟然悲剧啦,是申述呢,还是改投其他的杂志?size]投稿JMC,第一轮审稿意见,两个审稿人,一个对于文章的评价都很高,推荐小修后发表,第二个审稿人不同意发表,提了很多很难回答的问题,最后编辑请了第三个审稿人,结果第三个审稿人评价也很好,说第二个审稿人太苛刻,建议修改后发表,最后编辑给的minor revisionThank you for your recent submission to Journal of Materials Chemistry. I am pleased to inform you that your manuscript has been recommended for publication subject to revision in line with the attached reports. Two conflicting recommendations were initially received, so an adjudicative reviewer was consulted但是今天收到decision竟然是这样的,本来还以为不会在给第二个审稿人看了呢编辑给的意见如下: